Said is accused of shooting and killing Amina, 18, and Sarah, 17, in the back of his taxi in Irving, Texas after telling the two victims they were going for a ride to get food. A Warner Bros. He said he didn't want to raise "whores as daughters," Owens said. Note: there has been some minor editing. Yaser Abdel Said, a strict and controlling father, is suspected in the 2008 shooting death of his two daughters in Texas. Market data provided by Factset. Yaser Said, a taxi driver, is accused of murdering his two daughters in his cab on the night of Jan. 1, 2008. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, In their opening statements on Tuesday, prosecutors accused Said of killing his daughters because he was unhappy with them dating American boys outside their Islamic faith, according to ABC Dallas affiliate WFAA. Join Nancy Grace for her new online video series designed to help you protect what you love most your children. The couple married in February 1987 when the bridegroom was 30 while the bride The couple married in February 1987 when the bridegroom was 30 while the bride The evening the girls were killed, Said wanted to take just the two sisters to a restaurant. Yaser Said, who had been sought on a capital murder warrant since the slayings, was placed on theFBIs most-wanted list. On Christmas Day of 2007 four days after Amina wrote the e-mail the girls fled with Amina's boyfriend,Edgar Ruiz, Sarah's boyfriend,Erik Panameno,and the girls' mother, Patricia Owens Said, and rented an apartment in Oklahoma. Texas, when he met 15 year Way back in January 2008, the Dallas Morning News reported that Patricia had said (regarding Amina) that since they are Muslim that the daughter was [], Patricia Said, the wife of the murder Yaser Abdel Said, is the source of this information. IRVING, Texas (CBSDFW.COM) - The mother of two murdered teenage girls spoke to CBS 11 on Monday, Feb. 8, about her son's conviction for helping the alleged killer hide for 12 years. Performance & security by Cloudflare. Texas native Patricia Tissie Owens and Said are the parents of Islam Yaser-Abdel Said, Amina Said and Sarah Said.According to Owens, he was controlling and abusive throughout their relationship and over the years, she and their (FOX 4 Dallas-Fort Worth) Owens He said her last words to him were that she would never see him again. Authorities believe that the daughters were shot before 7:30 p.m. near the Omni Hotel. She had previously filed complaints with police against Said for touching her daughters in a sexual manner. 2021 CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved. Im dying. Hours later, the girls lifeless bodies were found, with multiple gunshots wounds, in Saids abandoned cab. It was dark, Watson told the court, but he could see one of the victims had her eyes fixed open and stuff was coming out of her nose.. Owens testified that "part of" her knew what her husband was capable of doing to her daughters while "part of" her did not. She agreed, despite the pleadings of her daughters, who insisted they didnt want to go back. Here is our latest episode. Most Popular #252724. Stop it. The former was nine and the latter eight, when they first told their grandmother about being sexually abused by Yaser. Im dying. Patricia Owens was just 15 in 1987 when she met 30-year-old Egyptian immigrant Yaser Said at the convenience store where he worked. Aquarius. He was captured in 2020 in Justin, Texas less than 30 miles northeast of the 2008 crime scene. A year after they married, she gave birth to their son, Islam. Criminals. According to Watsons testimony, a second taxicab driver investigated Saids vehicle after it hadnt moved up. Criminal. Patricia Owens, the mother of Amina and Sarah Said, took the stand Thursday. As I noted here, this is a woman who admitted in 2008 after her husband had killed their two daughters that her husband had threatened to kill one of her daughters for dating a non-Muslim. If there is an image appearing on this blog that belongs to you and you do not wish for it appear on this site, please E-mail with a link to said image and it will be promptly removed. If you are forwarding to a friend, please remove the unsubscribe buttons first, as they my accidentally click it. Patricia Owens confirms a photo of herself at age 14, a year before she married her former husband, Yaser Said, when he was 29. Email tips [email protected] or on Twitter at @audpants. We hope you enjoy the game as much as we do and join us as we unravel the clues in the latest box every month.https://popularcrime.com/recommends/hunt-a-killer/HASHTAGS#SarahSaid #AminaSaid #YaserAbdelSaid His son, Islam, and another relative were also arrested for harboring a fugitive. Said's ex-wife said she believes their son should go to prison for life for his role in aiding the fugitive. Within a week of returning home, the girls were dead. The FBI also arrested Saids son, 32-year-old Islam Yaser-Abdel Said, and brother, 59-year-old Yassein Abdulfatah Said, on Wednesday in Euless and charged both Owens reportedly claimed she had no idea where Said had been hiding for the past 12 years and she still doesnt understand his motive behind killing their children. In her final breaths, Sarah having been shot nine times managed to call authorities shortly after 7:30 p.m. and implicated her father in her death. (FOX 4 Dallas-Fort Worth). Sign up forOxygen Insiderfor all the best true crime content. *Previous footage prior to Saids capture*. Yaser Abdel Said Is A Member Of . Sarah Said was born March 6, 1990. Owens also sought a protective order. Owens divorced Said in 2009 and today, she still doesnt know why killed the girls. YASER SAID 'HONOR KILLINGS' TRIAL: DAUGHTER IN 911 CALL TELLS POLICE SHE'S 'DYING'. Contribute to chinapedia/wikipedia.en development by creating an account on GitHub. If you are forwarding to a friend, please remove the unsubscribe buttons first, as they my accidentally click it. Patricia Owens, the mother of Amina and Sarah Said, reportedly called her husband Yaser Said "the devil" while addressing the court during his 2022 capital murder Combien gagne t il d argent ? He became a permanent resident in the U.S., gaining full citizenship in 1997. Yaser Abdel Said Popularity . Authorities say Yaser Said, who was on the FBIs 10 Most Wanted list, shot the girls to inside his taxicab in Irving and abandoned their bodies inside the vehicle. For years priors to their deaths, the girls said they had been both physically and sexually abused by their father. Click to reveal While this verdict does not bring Sarah and Amina back, my office and this jury have done all that is in our power to see that justice is done., Saids public defender, Bradley Lollar, told CNN, We are disappointed in the verdict, but accept it. As I noted here, this is a woman who In 2008 Yaser Said, father of three shot and killed his teenage daughters Amina and Sarah in what was reported to be an honor killing. Yaser Said allegedly invited his daughter to a meal at Denny's before killing them. CNN Yaser Abdel Said was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole after being found guilty of capital murder in the 2008 killings of his two (FOX 4 Dallas-Fort Worth). Get all the stories you need-to-know from the most powerful name in news delivered first thing every morning to your inbox. Amina and Sarah Saids own mother, Patricia Tissie Owens, also known as Patricia Said, married Yaser when she was just 15-years-old, and lived under a cloud of abuse and domination at his hands. Authorities scrambled to learn the victims location, but Sarah was unable to provide an address to the emergency dispatcher. Patricia Owens confirms a photo of herself at age 14, a year before she married her former husband, Yaser Said, when he was 29. Authorities found the girls riddled with bullets inside their fathers cab, which was parked outside a hotel in Irving, Texas. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, Patricia Owens's husband was Yaser Abdel Said, whom she filed for divorce in 2009. Yaser Said had reportedly held each girl at gunpoint at different points in December 2007. Owens had dated his younger brother when she was 14 for "five or six months" before she met Said and got permission from her parents to marry him. Yaser Abdel Said ( ) is an Egyptian-American man who lived in Texas, United States.He is Muslim. The trial of Yaser Abdel Said is a ways off, but the legal wrangling has already started in Dallas County. "I hope every day he wakes up and sees his cell bars that memory of Amina and Sarah haunts him for the rest of his life. He controlled what they did, who they talked to, who they could be friends with, if theyand who theycould date. Jamie Glazov While she left Said several times throughout their marriage, Owens said she always returned out of fear. They had only known each other a few weeks when he declared he wanted to marry her, convincing her parents that he could provide her with a comfortable life. Attorney Joel Patton also repeatedly called into question Owens ability to answer questions, accusing prosecutors of leading her and stressing that some of the mothers allegations were false. One of the FBIs former top 10 most-wanted suspects, who is facing a trial 12 years after allegedly carrying out "honor killings" against his two daughters in Texas, took the stand on Monday and told the court, "I did not kill my daughters.". At the time, Amina would have been around 8 years old and Sarah would have been 7. WebKahden tyttrens murhasta vuonna 2008 syytetty Yaser Said oli vhll jd kiinni vuonna 2017, viranomaisten mukaan. 65 Year Olds. Discovery Company. / CBS Texas. You can change your choices at any time by clicking on the 'Privacy dashboard' links on our sites and apps. Yaser Abdel Said was born January 27, 1957 in Synai, Egypt. They also asked why he left his gun in his car if he was "scared.". Regardez le Salaire Mensuel de Jeff Fenholt Albums en temps rel. Yaser Said, a taxi driver, is accused of murdering his two daughters in his cab on the night of Jan. 1, 2008. (FOX 4 Dallas-Fort Worth). But [], Islam Said, a son of Yaser Said, who murdered Islams two sisters Amina and Sarah on January 1, 2008, denies that the killings were honor murders or had anything to do with Islam. WebHe married Patricia "Tissie" Owens in February 1987 when he was 30 and she was 15. Prosecutors present a 911 call from the moment on Jan. 1, 2008, when Yaser Said allegedly murdered his two daughters, in a Dallas courtroom during his trial on Aug. 4, 2022. IRVING, Texas Yaser Said was one of the most wanted men in world and had been on the run for more than a dozen years until he was caught in 2020. Prosecutors allege that Said eventually lured his daughters into his taxi, where Amina was sitting in the front passenger seat and Sarah was in the back. Honor killer yaser abdel said is now on fbi top 10 most wanted about time Family But, Owens ultimately returned to Yaser and took the girls to Hill County to recant the sexual abuse allegations. In the weeks leading up to the murders, prosecutors allege Said had grown angrier after feeling he had lost control of his wife and daughters, who had been dating non-Muslim men. Patricia later alleged that Said abused her during their marriage. I am so scared right now. Prosecutors present a 911 call from the moment on Jan. 1, 2008, when Yaser Said allegedly murdered his two daughters in a Dallas courtroom during his trial on Aug. 4, 2022, In a 911 call presented to a Dallas courtroom this week in the trial against Yaser Abdel Said, who is accused of killing his two daughters in 2008, one of his daughters can be heard frantically telling police, "I'm dying.". Said, who had worked as a taxi driver, faces an automatic life sentence if convicted. Texas father accused of fatally shooting his daughters. Your effort and contribution in providing this feedback is much (FOX 4 Dallas-Fort Worth). While there, Patricia repeated the horrifying truth more than once: "If the girls went back, Yaser would kill them." subscribe to the Crime Stories with Nancy Grace podcast. appreciated. He married Patricia Owens soon after in 1987 and obtained his green card. One of those times, she said, was in 1998 after her daughters accused him of abuse. Yaser Abdel Said the husband of Texas-native Patricia Tissie Owens did something horrible that has haunted his wife for years now. Quotes displayed in real-time or delayed by at least 15 minutes. The last time was fatal. After six days of trial, a Dallas County jury deliberated for three hours before returning a verdict of guilty Tuesday, the release said. Owens also testified that she made her daughters recant their statements to police and dropped charges against her husband after they returned home to Said. He controlled what they did, who they talked to, who they could be friends with, and who they could date, said prosecutor Lauren Black. I think Sarah wanted to fix things and Patricia kind of convinced us all it was going to be safe.. Regardez le Salaire Mensuel de Jeff Fenholt Albums en temps rel. Around Christmas in 2007, Owens helped her daughters plot to run away from home so that they could date their boyfriends. She and her sister, Sarah Said, 17, were found shot to death in their father's taxicab just 10 days later. After 12 years on the run, Yaser Said was arrested by federal agents in the town of Justin, Texas on August 26, 2020. ", SON OF YASER SAID, FBI 10 MOST-WANTED HONOR KILLINGS SUSPECT, PLEADS GUILTY TO CONCEALING HIM. His testimony comes days after jurors heard a 911 call Sarah Said made from a cellphone, telling the operator that her father shot her and she was dying. NEW YORK MAN INDICTED IN AMBUSH SHOOTING DEATH OF MOM PUSHING BABY IN STROLLER, "Amina hada few more months of school, and we were scared that it would mess up her credits for the college she wanted to go to," Owens testified. Then she walked out., Ruiz added, She knew she was going to die.. Yaser Abdel Said is an Egyptian and according to the FBI a resident of the United States. Now the girls can rest in peace. "I do not approve of what he has done by helping his dad stay hid," Owens said. Most Popular #252724. As Owens testified, Said sat emotionlessly across the room. She had fled home numerous times with the girls, but she continued to return to Said in Dallas because she was "scared" that he would hurt her, Owens said. (FOX 4 Dallas-Fort Worth), In a Dec. 21, 2007, email that was brought into evidence, Amina Said told one of her teachers that she and her sister planned to run away. Patricia Owens confirms a photo of herself at age 14, a year before she married her former husband, Yaser Said, when he was 29. A week before the sisters were killed, they and their mother left their home in the Dallas suburb of Lewisville and went to Oklahoma to get away from Said. TRIAL OF TEXAS MAN ACCUSED OF MURDERING DAUGHTERS IN HONOR KILLINGS FOR HAVING NON-MUSLIM BOYFRIENDS BEGINS. Owens said she hid their relationships from Said, whom she thought might "take away their phones" as punishment if he found out. Yaser Abdel Said, de 65 aos, tom el estrado este lunes en una corte en Dallas en donde dijo ser inocente de los cargos de asesinato que enfrenta por la muerte de sus hijas. Yaser Abdel Powered and implemented by FactSet Digital Solutions. In the e-mail, Amina accused her father of trying to set up an arranged marriage to which she had not consented later in the year. When he called 911, Watson told dispatchers the girls didnt look alive, according to The Dallas Morning News. Doomsday death & deception: Nancy Grace investigates Cult Mom Lori Vallow. Yaser Said was indicted by the state of Texas on Capital Murder charges and could face the death penalty if convicted. When the girls were in high school, they took up jobs at a Kroger grocery store, where Owens also worked, at which point they met two boys named Eric and Edgar who would eventually become their boyfriends. "I think they should stay in there they helped the killer take two lives so I think they should arrest them and take them to jail," said Owens. Said was on the FBIs Ten Most Wanted fugitive list since 2014 after he shot his two daughters to death while inside a taxi, in Irving, Texas. 2023 Cable News Network. Yaser Abdel Said: Mini Bio (1) Yaser Said was born on January 911 call in Yaser Said alleged 'honor killings' of his daughters. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. Owens testified that when she married Said, she was 15 and he was 29. 3:20 PM EDT, Wed August 10, 2022. Criminals. Her two daughters, Amina and Sarah, were born shortly afterward. (FOX 4 Dallas-Fort Worth) In a Dec. 21, We dont want police involved until we are totally ready, Amina continued. I seriously believe that his wife Patricia Owen's is a textbook case of battered women's/Stockholm syndrome. "Im dying, that's what's up. The couple had their first child, Islam, when Patricia was 16. WebYaser Said was born on January 27, 1957 in Sinai, Egypt. Through a translator, he answered yes. Sarah managed to call 911 after the shooting, but she was close to death, she told the dispatcher. Owens appearance marked the third day of testimony in the prosecutions presentation against Said, whom they allege was obsessed with possession and control. That control, Owens said, included choosing where the family would live and who they would communicate with. She wrote that she and her sister didnt want to live by the culture of their father, who was born in Egypt, nor did they want arranged marriages, as he planned. ", First published on February 8, 2021 / 3:15 PM. Saids brother, Yassein Said, and son, Islam Said, were later arrested in Euless, Texas and convicted of harboring a fugitive, according to CBS News. Before she died, Sarah made a brief, desperate call for help. Send it to The Daily Beasthere. February 8, 2021 / 3:15 PM All rights reserved. After Amina told her Owens had gone back to Said, Moggio testified that she told Amina to go to the police and file a restraining order against her father. He came to the U.S. on a student visa in 1983. Authorities didnt find the girls immediately after they couldnt determine the address through the 911 call. Please enter valid email address to continue. Said, a taxi driver, drove the girls in his taxi that evening. Black saidduring opening statementsthat Said was "obsessed with possession and control." I am very happy now, Owens told CBS DFW. Nathan Watson, 45 the hotel manager on duty on the night of the murders testified that he called 911 about an hour later to report the discovery of the teens bodies. The action you just performed triggered the security solution. Daniel Greenfield, Jihad Watch is a registered trademark of Robert Spencer in the United States and/or other countries - Site Developed and Managed by Free Speech Defense. Ex-wife slams devil Texas father Yaser Said over honor "I didnt think anything would happen," she testified. All rights reserved. He must now spend the rest of his days confined to a prison cell living under the control of the Texas Department of Criminal Justice, District Attorney Creuzot said. 2023 CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved. An FBI statement says agents arrested 63-year-old Yaser Abdel Said on Wednesday in Justin, 36 miles northwest of Dallas. At some point, Ruiz left to go to a New Year's Eve party back in Lewisville and, on Dec. 30, he got a text from Amina that her mom had convinced everyone else to go back to Texas to "run errands. Said was nowhere to be found and spent the next 12 years on the run. After her daughters' killings, Owens said she was diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and extreme depression, among other ailments, and she later divorced Said. Religion has nothing to do with it. Yet Islam Said has now been arrested in Texas along with his []. Patricia Said, the wife of the murder Yaser Abdel Said, is the source of this information. Owens A warrant for Yaser Abdel Said's arrest was issued the day after the 2008 shootings of his daughters, Sarah Yaser Said, 17, and Amina Yaser Said, 18. Mutual Fund and ETF data provided by Refinitiv Lipper. Patricia Owens told CBS 11 she still can't believe her own son, Islam Said, spent years helping his father hide from authorities for the murder of his sisters Amina and Sarah. Yaser Abdel Said remained a fugitive for more than 12 years. Here is what Patricia stated in an interview with CNN. The trio, plus Eric and Edgar, traveled to Tulsa, Oklahoma, for several days before eventually returning to their home with Said in Dallas so that Amina could finish school. authenticate users, apply security measures, and prevent spam and abuse, and, display personalised ads and content based on interest profiles, measure the effectiveness of personalised ads and content, and, develop and improve our products and services. Said testified for less than two hours on Monday, when prosecutors tried to poke holes in his claims. He testified that saw the sisters drive by with their father but not their mother in their father's taxi shortly thereafter. Yaser Abdel Said, a capital murder suspect wanted in connection with the homicide of his two teenage daughters, Amina and Sarah, was taken into custody without Market data provided by Factset. Ruiz testified on Tuesday that Patricia Owens Said showed up at his home around 5:00 p.m. and dragged Amina home, according to the Fort Worth Star-Telegram. "After she graduated high school, we were going to move back to Oklahoma.". The state wants to convict Yaser for being Muslim in 2008.. In late 2007, however, Owens managed to flee to Oklahoma with the girls, where she lived under a new name. SON OF YASER SAID, FBI TEN MOST WANTED HONOR KILLINGS SUSPECT, PLEADS GUILTY TO CONCEALING HIM, Sarah Said and Amina Said were allegedly shot to death by their father in what prosecutors have described as 'honor killings.' 2023 FOX News Network, LLC. WebGitHub export from English Wikipedia. Yaser was abusive.. "Oh my God, not again, Sarah continued in the call. Yaser Said reported his family missing to Lewisville police officer Jason Williams on Dec. 26, who claimed Said made an emotional plea. Get all the stories you need-to-know from the most powerful name in news delivered first thing every morning to your inbox. WebFormer husband of Patricia Owens. My daughters were loving, caring, smart, loved everybody, would help anybody. After filing police reports about Said allegedly abusing their daughters in the late 1990s, Owens fled to her sister's home in another part of Texas but eventually returned to Said. Then, after [], My latest in PJ Media: Yaser Said, who brutally murdered his two teenage daughters in Texas on New Years Day 2008 in an apparent honor killing, has finally been caught after being on the run for twelve years. He wanted me to go back to him and if I didnt go back to him, he threatened to kill me and my family, Owens said, adding that Said stated he wanted to kill her after she filed the charges. Many assumed he returned to his native Egypt, while some rumors placed him in New York City. They had only known Mutual Fund and ETF data provided by Refinitiv Lipper. MARYLAND MAN ACCUSED OF KILLING, DISMEMBERING DAUGHTER, YEARS AFTER ALLEGEDLY MURDERED SON AND FRIEND. Both girls had been shot numerous times, allegedly by their father inside a taxi cab. WebPatricia Owens, the mother of victims Amina Said and Sarah Said, told jurors her ex-husband was abusive and controlling. This website is using a security service to protect itself from online attacks. by Phyllis Chesler. Link your TV provider to stream full episodes and live TV. And he controlled everything in his household, prosecutor Lauren Black said during opening statements on Tuesday. Amina reportedly refused to return to her father's home when the group arrived back on New Year's Eve, opting instead to go to Ruiz's house. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. On New Years Day 2008, Said took his two daughters for a ride in his taxi. Yaser Abdel Said, 63, was arrested without incident in Justin, Texas on charges related to the killing of his two teenage daughters in January 2008. Owens, who spoke softly and often hesitantly on the stand, testified that Said eventually convinced her to return to Texas. Around the time, Sarah Said called 911 twice, stressing she was dying after her father shot her. There are several actions that could trigger this block including submitting a certain word or phrase, a SQL command or malformed data. Cloudflare Ray ID: 7a2b1cdae826e3a3 Patricia Owens confirms a photo of herself at age 14, a year before she married her former husband, Yaser Said, when he was 29. A year later, Amina was born, and then Sarah. WebGitHub export from English Wikipedia. Authorities say Yaser Said, who was on the FBIs 10 Most Wanted list, shot the girls to inside his taxicab in Irving and abandoned their bodies inside the vehicle. She said that Said left messages that he had changed and that he would leave the house if they didnt want him there. This horrifying case points up the reality that honor murder can happen even in Western countries. My dad shot me. Patricia Owens confirms a photo of herself at age 14, a year before she married her former husband, Yaser Said, when he was 29. 211.233.72.105 Owens was 15 years old when she married 29-year-old Yaser Yet, police arrested Isman, along with his uncle, Yasim Said; both are accused of helping the suspect evade capture. Yaser Said was convicted of capital murder Tuesday in the 2008 fatal shootings of his two teenage daughters, 18-year-old Amina Said and 17-year-old Sarah Yaser Said had been a fugitive from justice since This was the last time I would ever see her. Her aunt testified that she encouraged the girl to file for a restraining order against her father. Yaser Said moved in his chair as a 911 call played with his teen daughters final words on Wednesday, according to The Dallas Morning News. They were two of the most awesome kids in the world, and they did not deserve what happened to them.. Said is charged with capital murder, accused of killing 18-year-old Amina Said and 17-year-old Sarah Said on New Years Day in 2008. We, AOL, are part of the Yahoo family of brands. Ruiz testified on Tuesday that Patricia Owens Said showed up at his home around 5:00 p.m. and dragged Amina home, according to the Fort Worth Star-Telegram. Legal Statement. As CrimeOnline previously reported, FBI agents arrested Yaser Abdel Said, 63, without incident in Justin, Texas, on Wednesday,according to an FBI statement. Since then, shes been living a nightmare and hoping for justice. (FOX 4 Dallas-Fort Worth), Prosecutors also asked him why he would leave his daughters in his car if he feared he was being followed, as he had claimed. Content copyright Jihad Watch, Jihad Watch claims no credit for any images posted on this site unless otherwise noted. Patrica Owens, Yaser Said's ex-wife, testified before the jury Thursday morning and said why she fled her home with her daughters only to return days before they were killed. The mother added that part of her decision to bring the girls back to Dallas was so Amina could finish high school and not jeopardize her college scholarship. The fugitive was captured in 2020 after 12 years on the run. Oh my God. Yaser Said, 65, testified with the help of a translator on Monday inside a Dallas courtroom, where the defense rested later in the day. Oh my God. He will now be tried for the murder of his daughters. For the latest true crime and justice news,subscribe to the Crime Stories with Nancy Grace podcast. A friend reported that Said allegedly kicked Amina in the face for dating a non-Muslim boy and left welts all over her back. In the name of an honor killing, Defense attorney Joseph Patton said in opening statements that the evidence would not support a conviction and that police were too quick to focus on Said. 911 call in Yaser Said alleged 'honor killings' of his daughters. (Irving Police Dept. And when Owens was asked to identify her ex-husband in court, she pointed at Said and said, "That devil there. Yaser Abdel Said, 63, was arrested without incident in Justin, Texas on charges related to the killing of his two teenage daughters in January 2008. Robert Spencer in FrontPageMag ", It wasnt a group decision, Panameno testified of the move, according to the Morning News.