This would point to Ned and Chance Dutton being brothers of 1883s John Dutton Sr (grandfather of Kevin Costners John). Let's break it down. However, they are present in spirit during the series premiere episode. Ill add it to the list with the dinosaur bones! Therefore, his death would predate Elsas death and the Dutton familys arrival in Paradise Valley. The grave Summer first inquires about is clearly that of James Dutton, one of the main characters in 1883, whose 1893 death actually played out in Yellowstone Season 4, during a flashback in No Kindness for the Coward. Beyond the year matching, we also know its his because its next to those of wife Margaret and daughter Elsa, whose death is what sparked the family to settle down in Paradise Valley in the first place. The rest of the video (and what follows here) is the more detailed explanation. I have to think at least some of the alcohol served at this establishment is being spiked with stupid juice (as freshly squeezed from the stupid fruit), because what in Gods name did Ms. Hence, Elsas grave marks the foundation of the Yellowstone Dutton Ranch. The opening episode of 1923 reveals that Jacob rushed to save the family upon James' death. The Dutton Family are the owners of Yellowstone Dutton Ranch, the largest ranch in the United States and still growing. Additionally, I would have said the sheriffs decision to send Beth to jail was a dumb move, given whatever Dutton-originated firestorm is coming his way, but it was literally the only move he could have made with all those people around, particularly the woman threatening to press charges on Beth. There's also a complete graphic with the same information below. In short: Its a mystery inside a mystery. It made me wonder if they were burying them at the same time.. Appearances Season 1 Daybreak (episode 1) - Mentioned References Season 1, episode 1: Daybreak Others like you also viewed It also reveals Peter Dutton as John Dutton's (Costner) brother, a boy who died as a baby (revealed during Season 5 of Yellowstone). But as weve learned with Tate on more than one or two occasions, Yellowstone isnt above giving its younger characters a healthy dose of tragedies to harden their core Dutton-osity. By watching 1883, we know neither made the trip to Montana with James and Margaret. And, to repeat myself from an above comment, the headstones did not look that old; they weren't worn down or covered with lichen. It stands to reason that no one actually knows what became of her, or that she died under such circumstances that her body wasnt able to be transported back to the ranch, and thus a gravestone was erected to memorialize the woman, just without any physical remains in the earth below. But recently, one eagle-eyed fan on Reddit realized that Lee was actually absent from a number of flashback scenes when his character was still very much alive. 3 brings us to the modern-day Yellowstone. Those who watched 1883 remember a Crow elder telling McGraw's James Dutton that he could have the land he was sent to to bury his daughter, but in seven generations, the tribe would take it back. Eventually, James finds a piece of land with help from a Native American tribe leader. The third episode of 1923 (and simple math) makes it clear these men are not the same man. The Dutton family cemetery makes more sense after 1883 revealed that Elsa was the first person to be buried on the land.However, Yellowstone and its prequels have shown clips of headstones with names that fans have yet to meet, like Patience, Chance, and Ned Dutton. As is the case with James tombstone, Margarets has obvious signs of weathering that make things harder to read. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. We'll add a note here that in a previous Dutton Family tree video and article, we were adamant that McGraw's James was Costner's John's great-great-great grandson. Here's why it's likely that Coleman's character is Jack Dutton's (Mann) son. James Dutton (Tim McGraw), the lead of 1883 is John. Season 5 airing Sundays on Paramount Network beginning November 13th, 2022. Dutton, a sixth-generation rancher and devoted father, is immersed in a corrupt world where politicians are bought and sold by the world's largest oil and lumber corporations and land grabs make developers billions. We don't know too much about Chance, only that he is John's brother and may have. ---- That's no good. As the oldest Dutton son, Lee managed the Yellowstone Dutton Ranch and was expected to take over the ranch from John. New York, Whether that means trying to get pregnant again, swearing off sex forever, or something in between, I just dont want to see this couple haunted by their pasts forevermore. But in her case, it doesnt seem as if theres anything to read in a couple of key spots. Maybe Chance was James's brother, Ned's Dad. Never a dull moment for the Dutton family, which is also to say never a dull dinner. Likewise, fans have seen tombstones for Chance and Ned Dutton. As part of Taste of Country's comprehensive coverage of all things Yellowstone, check out our Dutton Rules podcast on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. The first part of this graphic explains how Jacob Dutton (Harrison Ford) from 1923 and James Dutton (Tim McGraw) from 1883 are related. 1. We found the Dutton ranch in real life. Therefore, it is safe to say that the Duttons will live and die on their land. Last appearance Speaking of hard-to-ascertain details. The series, a reimagination of the classic western genre in a contemporary setting, follows the fictional Dutton family who fights tooth and nail against enemies on every side as they hold onto their titular Yellowstone ranch in Montana, which is their home and family legacy. We don't know too much about Chance, only that he is John's brother and may have. Jamie is only one source of Beths recent ire (even though hes probably still tied to others), as shes also been spending quite a bit of time in flashback mode while working out some mental knots tied to her past with Rip and Rowdy. So he likely doesnt feel the same what if? pangs that Beth does, but the dying cattle plotline combined with heightened pressures to send Rips subconscious into the past as well, though for a more disturbing reason. "The idea that Kevin was only willing to work one week on . Both headstones and the style and size of the font of the engravings were the same, as well was the age and wear of the stone. I think theyre related to John Dutton 2 (Kevin Cs fathrr character). As the show progresses, we can only hope to learn about more members of the Dutton family. which phrase signals a contrast between ideals about marriage 304-539-8172; one level homes in clemmons, nc [email protected] Jamie and Lynelle need to present things as such, rather than acting like anything else matters to him. So whatever power Jamie thinks he has going into any future conversations with Sarah has a foundation of nothing sprinkled with imagination, which does not bode well for John, Beth and the ranch. So its coming. Only a handful of resting spots were highlighted, with weathering and age making things difficult to read, but considering they comprised both the oldest and newest inhabitants, I cant help but think this scene is hinting at reveals yet to come within this universe. Yellowstone kicked off the fourth episode of Season 5 with Beth in jail, having spent a night (and then far too much of the rest of the day) wearing her bar fight attire from the memorable evening prior. In the credits for S4-E1 the two young Dutton boys are listed as John Dutton Sr. (the older boy) and Spencer Dutton (the younger boy). An American series, Yellowstone, was released on 20 June 2018. Jacki Weavers Caroline Warner speaks of Sarah as if she herself is the code to the nuclear football, which makes a certain amount of sense if she wields similar fuck the world energy to that which Beth emanates at solar levels. The premiere offered a flashback to their barely-a-date that immediately went sideways, which scratched at her surviving regrets over not getting serious with him all those years ago. So did she really think she could get away with drunkenly assaulting someone in front of dozens of witnesses, or was this whole confrontation more of a convenient and easy way for Sheridan to sabotage the whiskey-adoring Dutton? Elizabeth Dutton Formally known as Elizabeth Strafford (Michelle Randolph), this character was set to marry Jack Dutton in 1923. Just trust us. Skip ahead to the6:00 mark of the above video for the 30-second version, uninterrupted. But that seems a bit one-note for the kind of storytelling that Taylor Sheridan has delivered so far, so Im expecting a situation that makes it clear why weve never heard anyone speaking fondly of Rowdy in the previous four seasons. Gil Birmingham. Like, I can get someone on the outer perimeter like Gator having a personal life away from the ranch, even if hes spending sooo much time cooking for the Duttons and various guests. Kevin Costner. On Ned's I could make out "March 16, 186__". And he was possibly thinking about how hed be able to further skew locational evidence before F&W would be able to get there by helicopter. The Yellowstone Dutton Ranch is exceptionally close to the family's hearts, and they choose to live and die on it. John frequently looks at one of the framed photos and there's another black-and-white version in Beth's room. But how long can that line of thinking last? Considering each move hes making is just widening the target on his back, and lengthening the list of people who are aiming at it, one would imagine hell have to quickly reach a point where he understands that breaking all the rules will make it harder to enforce the ones that are keeping his land safe. Elsa is buried on this land, and the Duttons settle on the property. On Neds I could make out March 16, 186__. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. John 2 mentions missing his dead son when we get that JD 2 and 3 flashback scene in season 2. Among them are Ned and Chance Dutton, whose lives and connections to John Dutton (Kevin Costner) remain unknown. 4.10 Grass on the Streets and Weeds on the Rooftops, 5.06 Cigarettes, Whiskey, a Meadow and You. 'Yellowstone' shows the graves of Ned and Chance Dutton In Yellowstone Season 5, Summer Higgins explores the Dutton family cemetery. John Dutton Sr. is the nephew and right hand man of Jacob Dutton. But it seems like all the tombstones that have popped up on the show belong only to relations, leaving viewers to wonder what happens to all of the various ranch employees that have helped do the Duttons dirty work for the past 100+ years? Like the dialogue noted above, this line could be taken two different ways. It'd be a crime to start with anyone other than the patriarch of the Dutton clan, whom the story has as the owner of the largest ranch . chance dutton headstone yellowstone. Since the idea of Tate wanting them to have another baby was mentioned just as many times as Kayce seeing the end of their relationship during his vision quest, it makes me more than wary about any attempts they make to get pregnant anew. Please refresh the page and try again. Finally, we get to the teal generation, which is Tate Dutton, his late baby brother John and by way of adoption Jamie Dutton's son, whose name isn't 100 percent clear. Now a happily married woman who is more than pleased to present herself as such, Beth remains conflicted over her past with Rip. Im more than a bit worried that. And one such person would be Market Equities latest weapon, Dawn Olivieris Sarah Atwood. When Summer asks who the grave belongs to, Monica answers with: For anyone not thinking too deeply about names and identities, the response is seemingly referring to the idea that James was the first within the family to settle on that land. My theory at the time was that Chance/ Ned suffered a similar death to Lee and it was going to be a plot point in S1. Clawing his eyes out with her bare hands may indeed be the only authentic way for her to sate the bloodthirst within. Therefore, several members of the family are buried on the land. Wes Bentleys Jamie was allowed just a couple of all-too-brief moments to feel anything resembling positivity or victory, including being allowed to introduce John as the new governor, and when John rebuked Beths refusal to make her brother a glass of whiskey. While the gravestones are partially blocked by grass, fans were able to identify a date on Neds gravestone as March 16, 1863. 10:52 PM The dog ripped the pillow to shreds/pieces. And all such memories undoubtedly pull at the dangling thread of her abortion and unconsenting sterilization, which remains a buried landmine in their relationship; one whose triggering could bring Jamies life to a brutal end, depending on how Rip would take such news. The Duttons protect their land generation after generation because it is the resting place of their ancestors. Yellowstone gave viewers an impromptu throwdown that mirrored Season 4s last man standing brawl between Lloyd and Walker. Not that he wont bite back harder. Paramount Network's 'Yellowstone' is the story of the Dutton family, who own the largest ranch in America. Take these two Duttons, for example. But as fellow Redditor AnnaNonna points out, I dont think any of us know for sure who they are. Also expectedly, Rip wasnt exactly a gentleman during that exchange. Edit/Wild Theory Addition: It is possible the semi-obscured date on Ned's was 1(9)86. But no, theres just a little too much going on behind her eyes to squash all suspicions outright. [1] Chance's birth date and the date of his death are unknown. Fans of the show may remember hearing the names Chance and Ned Dutton. Thanks to Rubys sleuthing, however, we do know that at least Ned Dutton wouldve been a contemporary of 1883s John Dutton Sr., played by tiny Audie Rick for that series (in the Yellowstone Season 4 flashback, hes played by another, older actor). (Not to mention Margarets stone also showcasing the upper-case usage.). He ran off, trying to survive, and. Dave Annable, who plays Lee, hasn't mentioned a return to Dutton Ranch, but it's still possible that his character will appear. The second is John Dutton's (Costner) father, played by Dabney Coleman in Yellowstone.